*note: This is another Sopranos related entry. If you haven’t seen the episode in question, skip this entry, as it’s full of spoilers for episode 3*
I have mixed feelings about this episode. Unlike the vast majority of my friends and associates, I really enjoyed Tony as Kevin Finnerty. I knew it wouldn’t last long but as I stated in my last Soprano’s entry, I am fascinated by the whole “Tony in Limbo” thing and the inner workings of his soul. How does a man who lives his life in such a way reconcile his evil actions?
But alas, I think David Chase knew that he was pushing it with two whole episodes of comatose Tony and as we were shown by the actions of the crew without Tony, those guys are rudderless out there, no one is ready, willing, or able to take over the mantle at this point. It just makes that little miniature confrontation that Sil and Tony had regarding what to do about Tony B. at the end of last season ring all the more true. Sil really wasn’t ready physiologically or psychologically to take up the mantle.
Vito (the gay and suddenly MUY ambitious, albeit slimmer, mobster) is being made purposefully annoying. Like there is nothing endearing about him as opposed to Ralphy who was an intriguing character at least. Vito is actually less likable than Ritchie Aprile, which of course means that he’s being set up for a hard fall. I think most of the audience is about sick of him as they were of Kevin Finnerty. I don’t think it’s going to be pretty, and imagine how this sets Phil off, losing another “relative”, though this one by marriage?
Anyway back to Kevin Finnerty. So in my eyes these sequences were more straight forward and “about business”. He gets the “summons” to deal with the monks. I see that as him trying to deal with some of the sins he has tried to pass along to others. He even almost acknowledges as much when he says he isn’t Kevin Finnerty, but he still feels like he needs to make up for whatever Finnerty’s done. He eventually relents but it was an honest effort on his part.
He struggles to tell his “limbo wife” about his diagnosis of Alzheimers because he is beginning to not only accept it, but believe that he in fact is Finnerty.
When he finds the invitation to the reunion I think that seals the deal for him….and later for us.
We get a glimpse of how close he is to coming back when Paulie almost talks him to death as “Finnerty” bangs on the wall (the fourth wall?…if you are unfamiliar with the term, it represents that fictional wall that keeps TV characters out of our world, or in this case, Tony out of the “real world”) for him to keep it down. It was hilarious that even comatose, Paulie is stressful to deal with!
Seeing his cousin Tony B. as the host, I don’t think he really recognized him as just that. We see kids running around, and they very well may represent Meadow and A.J., but I saw them more in fitting with the theme of a “reunion”. Tony wasn’t drawn to them after all.
The briefcase, “with his entire life”, was just that…his entire life. I’m not so sure that the house was either heaven or hell. It was probably neither as Chase seems sort of non-committal on the whole thing, but regardless Tony would have had to have “let go” of his former life to access it, and as it turns out he still had “business to attend to”.
As this is going on we hear the voice of Meadow. Meadow was represented in the first episode’s opening montage as “Khu” the guardian angel. Here we see/hear her as just that. She’s the voice that Tony ultimately responds to (though in his comatose state he hears her as much more child like). And just like that, Tony is out! Back to the real world where I’m sure the likes of OJ and Geoff want him.
Honestly, I don’t see how the story arcs that were developed in the meanwhile are more intriguing than the journey into Tony’s psyche, but now we’ll get to see if Christopher’s movie, “Cleaver” comes to fruition, I’m sure that’ll be fun (that was sarcasm)! Vito versus everyone will be interesting (genuine this time).
I don’t think we’re done by a long shot with AJ as a matter of fact, I still stand behind what I said in the last Sopranos related entry. I think AJ is going to die. He’s no Michael Corleone, no matter how many Godfather lines he throws out there (Difficult but not impossible….). If anyone shapes up to be a Michael Corleone (and thanks to whoever at TWoP mentioned this analogy) it’s Meadow. She’s the brains of this outfit.
Anyway those are my thoughts/interpretations on the episode. I may be wrong, but that’s how I see it.